2024 - 2025 Season 23
- September/October 2024 - The Minutes by Tracy Letts
2023 - 2024 Season 22
- May 2024 - Sleeping Giant by Steve Yockey
- February/March 2024 - Until the Flood by Dael Orlandersmith
- December 2023 - POTUS, Or, Behind Every Great Dumbass are Seven Women Trying to Keep Him Alive by Selina Fillinger
- September/October 2023 - Gloria by Branden Jacobs-Jenkins
2022 - 2023 Season 21
- May 2023 - Ithamar Has Nothing to Say by Ithamar Enriquez
- April/May 2023 - Fairview by Jackie Sibblies Drury
- December 2022 - La Ruta by Isaac Gómez
- September/October 2022 - Ghosts of Bogotá by Diana Burbano
2021 - 2022 Season 20
- May 2022 - Assassins - music and lyrics by Stephen Sondheim, book by John Weidman, based on an original concept by Charles Gilbert Jr.
- March 2022 - Sheepdog by Kevin Artigue
- October/November 2021 - Our Dear Dead Drug Lord by Alexis Scheer
- September/October 2021 - Bright Colors And Bold Patterns by Drew Droege
2020 - 2021 Season 19 - IN-PERSON PERFORMANCES CANCELLED DUE TO COVID
- November/December 2020 - Archival Streaming of A Very Merry Unauthorized Children's Scientology Pageant from 2008
2019 - 2020 Season 18 - FINAL SHOW CANCELLED DUE TO COVID
- February 2020 - The Wolves by Sarah DeLappe
- November 2019 - American Psycho The Musical book by Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa, music and lyrics by Duncan Sheik, based on the novel by Bret Easton Ellis
- August 2019 - Small Mouth Sounds by Bess Wohl
2018 - 2019 Season 17
- April/May 2019 - Let the Right One In by Jack Thorne based on the novel and screenplay by John Ajvide Lindqvist
- January/February 2019 - Two Mile Hollow by Leah Nanako Winkler
- November 2018 - The Cake by Bekah Brunstetter
- September 2018 - The Antipodes by Annie Baker
2017 - 2018 Season 16
- May 2018 - Silence! The Musical book by Hunter Bell, Music and Lyrics by Jon & Al Kaplan
- March 2018 - Gidion's Knot by Johnna Adams (co-production with Tempe Center for the Arts)
- February 2018 - Hand to God by Robert Askins (co-production with Phoenix Theatre)
- November/December 2017 - Mercury* by Steve Yockey (co-World Premiere with Salt Lake Acting Company)
*ZONI AWARD BEST OVERALL PRODUCTION - NON-CONTRACTED PLAY* - September/October 2017 - Kiss by Guillermo Calderón
2016 - 2017 Season 15
- April/May 2017 - Hir by Taylor Mac
- March 2017 - Native Son by Nambi E. Kelley based on the novel by Richard Wright
- November/December 2016 - Anything You Hear and Only Half of What You See by Ron Hunting
- October/November 2016 - The Trump Card by Mike Daisey, adapted by Stray Cat Theatre
- September/October 2016 - John by Annie Baker
2015 - 2016 Season 14
- June/July 2016 - Green Day's American Idiot by Green Day, book by Billie Joe Armstrong and Michael Mayer
- March 2016 - Stupid Fucking Bird by Aaron Posner
- February 2016 - Sex With Strangers by Laura Eason (Tucson Run - a co-production with Arizona Theatre Company)
- December 2015 - Heathers: The Musical by Laurence O'Keefe and Kevin Murphy
- September/October 2015 -- Sex With Strangers by Laura Eason (Phoenix Run - a co-production with Arizona Theatre Company)
2014 - 2015 Season 13
- April/May 2015 -- The Tomkat Project by Brandon Ogborn
- February/March 2015 -- Pluto by Steve Yockey
- December 2014 -- Year of the Rooster by Eric Dufault
- September/October 2014 -- The Brothers Size* by Tarell Alvin McCraney
*ZONI AWARD BEST OVERALL PRODUCTION - NON-CONTRACTED PLAY*
2013 - 2014 Season 12
- April/May 2014 -- The Elaborate Entrance of Chad Deity by Kristoffer Diaz
- February/March 2014 -- The Whale by Samuel D. Hunter
- December 2013 -- All New People by Zach Braff
- September/October 2013 -- The Flick by Annie Baker
2012 - 2013 Season 11
- April/May 2013 -- Chicks With Dicks by Trista Baldwin
- Feb/March 2013 -- Sons of the Prophet by Stephen Karam
- December 2012 -- Wolves* by Steve Yockey
*ZONI AWARD BEST OVERALL PRODUCTION - NON-CONTRACTED PLAY* - September 2012 -- punkplay by Gregory S. Moss
2011 - 2012 Season 10
- May/June 2012 -- Heddatron by Elizabeth Meriwether
- Feb/March 2012 -- The Last Days of Judas Iscariot by Stephen Adly Guirgis
- December 2011 -- MilkMilkLemonade by Joshua Conkel
- September 2011 -- The Sparrow by Nathan Allen, Chris Mathews and Jake Minton
2010 - 2011 Season 9
- May 2011 -- Abraham Lincoln's Big, Gay Dance Party by Aaron Loeb
- March 2011 -- Octopus by Steve Yockey
- December 2010 -- Learn to be Latina* by Enrique Urueta
*ZONI AWARD BEST OVERALL PRODUCTION - NON-CONTRACTED PLAY* - September 2010 -- reasons to be pretty by Neil LaBute
2009 - 2010 Season 8
- April 2010 -- 12th Night of the Living Dead by William Shakespeare Adapted by Brian MacInnis Smallwood
- February 2010 -- The Play About the Naked Guy by David Bell
- December 2009 -- Speech and Debate* by Stephen Karam
*ZONI AWARD BEST OVERALL PRODUCTION - NON-CONTRACTED PLAY* - September 2009 -- Blackbird by David Harrower
2008 - 2009 Season 7
- April 2009 -- columbinus* by The United States Theatre Project
*ZONI AWARD BEST OVERALL PRODUCTION - NON-CONTRACTED PLAY* - February 2009 -- An Impending Rupture of the Belly by Matt Pelfrey
- December 2008 -- A Very Merry Unauthorized Children’s Scientology Pageant by Kyle Jarrow, based on a concept by Alex Timbers
- September 2008 -- Everything Will Be Different: A Brief History of Helen of Troy by Mark Schultz
2007 - 2008 Season 6
- April 2008 -- Pulp* by Patricia Kane
*ZONI AWARD BEST OVERALL PRODUCTION - NON-CONTRACTED MUSICAL* - February 2008 -- Kate Crackernuts by Sheila Callaghan
- November 2007 -- Dog Sees God: Confessions of a Teenage Blockhead by Burt V. Royal
- September 2007 -- A Number by Caryl Churchill
2006 - 2007 Season 5
- April 2007 -- Fatal Attraction: A Greek Tragedy by Kate Wilkinson & Alana McNair
- February 2007 -- 4.48 Psychosis by Sarah Kane
- November 2006 -- Fat Pig by Neil LaBute
- September 2006 -- Falling Petals by Ben Ellis
2005 - 2006 Season 4
- May 2006 -- Trainspotting by Irvine Welsh, adapted by Harry Gibson
- February 2006 -- Kimberly Akimbo by David Lindsay-Abaire
- February 2006 -- The 4th Graders Present an Unnamed Love-Suicide by Sean Graney (PVCC X-Fest)
- October 2005 -- The 4th Graders Present an Unnamed Love-Suicide by Sean Graney
- October 2005 -- Nicky Goes Goth by Elizabeth Meriwether (After Dark Series)
2004 - 2005 Season 3
- June 2005 -- Wordplay(s): 3 Selections from All In The Timing by David Ives (Herberger Lunch Time Theater)
- May 2005 -- Stop Kiss by Diana Son
- February 2005 -- The Normal Heart by Larry Kramer
- November 2004 -- [sic] by Melissa James Gibson
- September 2004 -- Poona the Fuckdog and other plays for children by Jeff Goode (After Dark Series)
2003 - 2004 Season 2
- May 2004 -- Anthony Burgess' A Clockwork Orange
- February 2004 -- Wonder of the World by David Lindsay Abaire
- January 2004 -- Hellcab by By Will Kern (Herberger Lunch Time Theater)
- November 2003 -- Patty Red Pants by Trista Baldwin
- November 2003 -- Hysteric Studs by Charlotte Mann (After Dark Series)
2002 - 2003 Season 1
- April 2003 -- The Laramie Project by Moisés Kaufman and the Members of Tectonic Theater Project
- March 2003 -- The Lysistrata Project: Lysistrata 2024
- February 2003 -- This Is Our Youth by Kenneth Lonergan
- November 2002 -- The Dianalogues by Laurel Haines
2001 - 2002 - The Scattered Beginnings...
- June 2002 -- bash: latter day plays by Neil Labute
- November 2001 -- Stupid Kids by John C. Russell